Captain Courageous?

Let me start with a confession. In fact, it’s something that probably everyone who knows me has known. I was never a fan of MS Dhoni. I liked his keeping, his batting to a large extent, but always felt he was no good on tracks friendlier to bowlers. And his captaincy, I just thought he was at the right place at the right time. Tendulkar clicked and he won the VB series. A new India clicked as he won the 20-20 world cup in 2007. Chennai played well with firepower in the form of Hayden and Murali. He never really had to do much I felt. (I know people will complain about this, and there will be a lot of hate mail and hate chat over this.)

I might be a sadist, but there is a part of me that waits to see people fail. Not that it is a matter of immense pleasure for me watching people fail. I kinda feel failure brings out the best in people. Like Rahul Dravid, who after the 2007 WC loss, went off on a holiday and said its just a game. Loved it!

Well, coming to the topic. MSD failed with Chennai. He was open in asking his bowlers to step up and deliver! Even to the point of berating them on TV right after the toss. There was no holding things back, no hidden behind-the-scenes stuff. What is wrong is wrong. After all, people who follow cricket are no fools.

Then, there was the T20 world cup loss. There are many who say he made bad decisions and then there are some who say he was plain unlucky as T20 is a format where you can’t say what can happen when (in the same breath, will they agree that he was just lucky winning the last one?). For me the defining moment was when he was open enough to admit that he made a mistake holding back Yuvraj, and that they failed against the shorter stuff. Its a matter of much speculation what Yuvraj could/would have done against shorter stuff. But it shows a lot of courage from MSD in accepting his mistakes in public, especially in a country where most captains usually come up with a line about how it was a gamble and could’ve gone either way, and they’d have been lauded if it went right, blah blah blah. I know India will bounce back again for the Champions trophy. They will remain a force to reckon with even if they get ‘bounced’ out of tournaments. Only because there’s a man at the top who is honest enough to admit his mistakes and learn from them. Way to go MSD!


3 thoughts on “Captain Courageous?

  1. They were tired, totally agree with coach Gary Kirsten. They might say that at this level, you have to put up with lots of matches. Yes, but they are human after all.
    I don’t think they were lucky to win the last one. I mean the enthusiasm and the spirit did it as it always done for the Indian game. This was lacking in this WC.
    I could see that Dhoni was totally a ‘goner’ in the first game itself. Damn IPL. I don’t think IPL should be held every year. It is alright with games like Soccer and Tennis, but IPL is lot of work in 1.5 months.

    1. Its not the IPL that’s the problem…its the scheduling of the world cup so close to it 😛
      Fatigue might have been a big factor…but watching them lose to WI and Eng, I think they need to work on their batting sometime…MSD is also out of form sadly…the big shots which made him famous are just not there…
      His hair is turning gray…(there was a pic which I wanted to put up, but there were copyright issues)…plus he’s losing his cool way more often…makes you wonder, if the job of the Indian cricket team captain might just be too much of a hot potato for anyone…it burned Sachin, Dravid and to some extent even Kumble…even Ganguly lost his form and his place in the team after holding on for 5 years…

      1. damn these World Cups , u know what …the next one is gonna be held in 1 yrs time … so not a big deal
        T20 was always a bit of gamble … Dhoni has a decent game , a cool head and also has lots of luck which is what made him such a grand success as captain.
        law of averages was bound to catch up sometime
        T20 WC wasnt as much fund as IPL dude ! given the kind of contests during IPL , I felt WC was much tamer
        IPL had to be held in April-May no other time and it must have been good practice too … its just our bad luck tht 3-4 key players were out of form.
        But again as u said we are a champion team and will certainly bounce back hard

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s